Log in | Register
Forum > Site Discussion > Thread

Who would have been the most subscribed name on GWM back in 2009?

Who would have been the most subscribed name on GWM back in 2009? (243 total votes)

Cindy Phillips (55, 22.6%)
Melissa Dettwiller (29, 11.9%)
Katka Kyptova (28, 11.5%)
Lindsey Cope (27, 11.1%)
Eva Andressa Vieira (15, 6.2%)
Britt Miller (14, 5.8%)
Angela Salvagno (9, 3.7%)
Mindi O'Brien (8, 3.3%)
Natalia Trukhina (7, 2.9%)
Jodi Miller (7, 2.9%)
Brigita Brezovac (7, 2.9%)
Sharon Bruneau (6, 2.5%)
Erica Cordie (6, 2.5%)
Pauline Nordin (5, 2.1%)
Macey Boudreau (5, 2.1%)
Jaime Koeppe (4, 1.6%)
Lenda Murray (3, 1.2%)
Emmanuela Pintus (2, 0.8%)
Laura Harris Aka Chicken Tuna (2, 0.8%)
Tara Scotti (1, 0.4%)
Heidi Vuorela (1, 0.4%)
Roxie Rain (1, 0.4%)
Jody May (1, 0.4%)
Gracyanne Barbosa (0, 0.0%)
Melissa Froio (0, 0.0%)
cgsweat
May 01, 2026 - permalink

If GWM had the subscription system since the beginning, who do you think would have been the most subscribed model?

I'm going to list as many names as I can to fill up the 25 option limit. Let me know if there are any that I missed.

Please keep in mind that I'm considering those who were at their peak, or those who had already peaked by then or, at the very least, were gaining popularity fast. For example, Fabiola Boulanger's first upload was in December 2009, so she very likely wouldn't have been the most subscribed model that year. I might regret including her, but Natalia Trukhina was technically on the rise that year, although she looked nothing like she does now, so please keep that in mind when voting. Dani Reardon's first upload was from 2008, but she only had 5 more images uploaded in 2009 until Dec of that year, so I'll have to exclude her (much to my own dismay).

Another consideration was their popularity on paysites at the time. So, even though they might not have had many images on this site, their popularity on sites like Herbiceps, FTVideo, Awefilms or Krivsstudio might have had users subscribing to their names here for updates.

I included throwbacks to those of you who remember them. I remember some of them being very popular, even if they may or may not have been my own personal favorites.

I'm going to be evil and only allow 1 answer. 😈

May 01, 2026 - permalink

Other: Kristy Hawkins

May 01, 2026 - permalink

Gina Davis

May 01, 2026 - permalink

Definitely these two…

May 01, 2026 - edited May 01, 2026 - permalink

Maybe Heather armburst or Larissa reis. There are a few from that Era who were super hot but never had a lot of pictures

May 01, 2026 - permalink

I'm surprised it's not closer between Cindy and Britt.

Honestly I'm not good at remembering who was where with their popularity at a specific time, but I just know at this time when I was into Jodi (who still looks amazing), Lindsey, Cindy and Britt, I was also into

Moorea Wolfe

Lindsay Dejager

Celeste Bonin

May 01, 2026 - permalink

Cinderella Landolt?

May 01, 2026 - edited May 01, 2026 - permalink

If I remember Jamie Eason was quite popular back then too

cgsweat
May 02, 2026 - permalink

I'm surprised it's not closer between Cindy and Britt.

I think Cindy was always more favored over Britt, but I am surprised by how much (23 vs. 3). Maybe I should have enabled multiple votes.

Cinderella Landolt?

There is unfortunately no data for me to look up. I know she gained popularity several years ago but I don't remember exactly how far back she goes.

May 02, 2026 - permalink

Cinderella Landolt?

I think she started after 2010 or at least her pictures are from after 2010

May 02, 2026 - permalink

What about Monica Mollica. I remember she also used to go under her name Monica Mowi. She had insane legs, and flexibility. There are not many pics from 2009 or before on this site, but I am pretty sure she was already active. Not sure when she started to grow big, but this pic is from 2009 on the site:

May 02, 2026 - permalink

Jennifer Cowan

May 04, 2026 - permalink

The level of development is shockingly low. Britt and Cindy where competing in BB.

May 06, 2026 - permalink

If I remember Jamie Eason was quite popular back then too

Oh yeah, Jamie would have been HUGE on here. She was almost getting "Mainstream Popular" online for a bit there (a great crossover from FBBS to "normal hot girls" most guys would accept) before getting married and deliberately stopping because she wanted to get pregnant. That pretty much ended her fame, unfortunately.

I think Chyna would be low-key HUGE on here at that point, even if that was past her prime.

May 06, 2026 - permalink

Would have to be Cindy Phillips. I remember first coming here around that time. Everybody was obsessed with her. But I voted for Katka.

May 06, 2026 - permalink

I voted for Melissa Detwiller because her contentsback in the day were amazing, but I’m surprised that Roxie Rain didn’t receive any votes, guys look at this masterpiece…

May 06, 2026 - permalink

Come on guys, who would resist in front this sexy beauty in 2009…

Chainer
May 07, 2026 - permalink

I wrote a script to go through models' images from before 2010 and add up the number of favorites; here's what I got (the top 40):

Name                                     | Favorites (< ~2018*) | Images (< 2010)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eva Andressa Vieira                      | 4,650             | 66             
Cindy Phillips Hodgkinson (cindyhodgk... | 4,386             | 107            
Heidi Vuorela                            | 3,343             | 128            
Laura Harris Aka Chicken Tuna            | 3,266             | 159            
Sarah De Herdt                           | 2,838             | 42             
Pauline Nordin                           | 2,760             | 52             
Kristifigure                             | 2,714             | 84             
Linda Fodor                              | 2,599             | 39             
Britt Miller                             | 2,373             | 43             
April Rincones                           | 2,348             | 101            
Megan Abshire                            | 2,302             | 60             
Katka Kyptova                            | 2,241             | 76             
Erika Andersson                          | 2,228             | 54             
Lyndsay Dejager                          | 2,196             | 26             
Norah Josephsen                          | 2,109             | 28             
Diana Tyuleneva                          | 2,060             | 44             
Macey Boudreau                           | 2,038             | 26             
Natalia Inoue (aka Natty Raney)          | 2,002             | 17             
Caroline Wigert                          | 1,983             | 15             
Timea Majorova                           | 1,893             | 39             
Eva Kovalainen                           | 1,830             | 69             
Aubrie Richeson                          | 1,517             | 25             
Arina Manta                              | 1,514             | 52             
Erin Stern                               | 1,507             | 26             
Mindi O'Brien                            | 1,502             | 19             
Louise Rogers-Kayim                      | 1,500             | 17             
Ana Usategui                             | 1,487             | 12             
Nataliya Kuznetsova (amazonka)           | 1,470             | 52             
Kortney Olson                            | 1,463             | 33             
Lory                                     | 1,461             | 22             
Jodi Leigh Miller                        | 1,430             | 32             
Lindsey Cope                             | 1,412             | 14             
Madelene Bengtsson                       | 1,385             | 72             
Hayley McNeff                            | 1,371             | 51             
Michi Ritz                               | 1,342             | 23             
Tabitha Klausen                          | 1,228             | 23             
Gina Bonfiglio                           | 1,220             | 57             
Melissa Dettwiller                       | 1,219             | 19             
Andrea Bisi                              | 1,205             | 24             
Anne Freitas                             | 1,155             | 22 

I wish I could have counted exactly the favorites that were given before 2010, but unfortunately I didn't start keeping track of favorite timestamps until 2018 so I have to make do with that. This means that models who became popular after 2009 such that people went back and favorited their earlier (pre-2010) pics more would be overrepresented on this list.

cgsweat
May 07, 2026 - permalink

Surprised Chicken Tuna maintained that much popularity past 2018.

Do you have a copy of the old system, on the 0-10 scale? A script that could analyze that might produce more accurate results (not to judge the accuracy of this list).

Chainer
May 07, 2026 - permalink

Surprised Chicken Tuna maintained that much popularity past 2018.

No, I meant that my table above counts all the favorites made before 2018 (since these are the ones whose date is unknown), on images uploaded before 2010. If I knew their dates, I could further filter them to the ones made before 2010, which would be better. So the table doesn't say anything about anyone's popularity after 2018, those are the favorites which are definitely not counted.

I don't think I've kept a copy around of the old 0-10 ratings.

May 07, 2026 - permalink

Brazilians were already topping the charts even in an era with limited social media and no decent phone cameras.

They are over the top today dominating every corner of the site.

cgsweat
May 07, 2026 - permalink

No, I meant that my table above counts all the favorites made before 2018 (since these are the ones whose date is unknown), on images uploaded before 2010.

Oh. So the the "favorites" system existed before 2018, it just wasn't tracked until then?

Chainer
May 07, 2026 - permalink

Just the date/time at which each favorite was made wasn't tracked. So if a favorite doesn't have a date attached, it's from before 2018. (These dates are not visible in the UI, but they are in the database.)

6 days ago - permalink

This is such a tough list, but I went with Angela Salvagno.

« first < prev Page 1 of 2 next > last »