After. Bigger is always better. No doubt she's cuter before. But I'm here for muscles.
I will say that whatever PEDs she's on didn't mess up her face. Her face looks almost the same before and after.
She now often looks puffed up - like she's chewing a wasp ! Personally she's one of those who I do not find appealing in her recent states. Could never see her popularity - though I suppose I can if I tried, but she does little for me. I have millions of pics and thousands of video in my collection and none of her. Sure she got bigger but facially and tonally not great - she's one of those whose over use of enhancements does her few favours IMO.
She now often looks puffed up - like she's chewing a wasp !
You explained it perfectly. It does scratch an itch, but it looks a bit uncomfortable.
Tough call, but giving the edge to after. I definitely think she's prettier in the before, but I just can't resist how massive she is in the after.