Log in | Register
Forum > Site Discussion > Thread

"Why was this pic deleted?"

« first < prev Page 41 of 42 next > last »
5 days ago - permalink

Ok. While I can definitely understand why someone might delete these Aline Dessine pics, (I'm personally of the opinion that) there is clearly discernible muscle mass in both of them, and especially in the top one. I'm usually not one to complain about removals, but these ones I'm not too happy about.

/rant

5 days ago - permalink

Simply having mildly toned vertical ab lines is something pretty much any bikini model has, I usually consider horizontal abs definition to be the minimum when it comes to muscularity for the site, if it's pretty much just an abs-focused shot.

5 days ago - edited 5 days ago - permalink

From a moderator standpoint, we also look at images within the context of a models’s “body of work“ so to speak. In addition to being very well liked, she has a good nine pages worth of images here. She’s one of those models who generates a lot of consistent material. There will almost certainly be future opportunities for upload, and better ones at that.

5 days ago - permalink

Yeah I understand. I was just surprised given that similar pics are frequently shared here to seemingly great acclaim. No worries.

tamarok
5 days ago - permalink

I’m certainly not seeing discernible muscle here. Most of it is clothing that covers it up. For me it extremely borderline at best, but wouldn’t be worth approving if it came through the manual queue.

5 days ago - permalink

I see. Always interesting and insightful to hear people's reasoning even if I don't personally agree with it. Thanks for the heads-up.

5 days ago - edited 5 days ago - permalink

I reported the second one but not the first one. In the second all you can see of body skin is a slim waist - no discernible abs - zero muscle on view - while the rest of her is covered in baggy clothing with a rounded bum but not what this site is about. Got to admit IMO that model gets more dubious upvotes and undeserved passes for minimal visible muscle than almost anyone else on here (some of her pics are fine , others not), but at the end of the day, it's the Mods call.

4 days ago - permalink

Seriously?

4 days ago - permalink

"seriously.....?" I didn't see these. I'm not a mod, but I do occasionally report photos with questionable visible muscularity.

These are borderline in my thinking, sort of reminding me of "skinny beach chicks" with a little ab muscle, chest "enhancements," and toothpick arms that some guys like to post. Maybe posting just one instead of two would have been a better approach.....

Chainer
4 days ago - permalink

Sometimes I reject "skinny with abs" style posts if there is nothing else noteworthy, and in this case we have no idea if she has other notable muscle, nor can we even see her face. I think it's a bit borderline but rejection is not uncalled for.

tamarok
4 days ago - permalink

There are also many existing similar variants of this model, which are already borderline, so these two images were adding nothing to the site.

Chainer
4 days ago - permalink

There are also many existing similar variants of this model, which are already borderline, so these two images were adding nothing to the site.

Oh that's a great point, in this case I forgot to look at already existing images of her; the fact that there are already a good number of them and these two aren't adding much moves them more firmly into the "reject" pile.

3 days ago - permalink

I generally understand when you remove an image, but I think there's a problem with the judgment on the removal of this photo of Belen. The girl has her back to the camera, and the focus of the image isn't on her breast.

Especially when there are images that have been uploaded that clearly show a nipple, frontally, but under fishnets or transparent clothing. Where do we draw the line?

Chainer
3 days ago - permalink

If you want to argue that it is not an adult image, go ahead...

Especially when there are images that have been uploaded that clearly show a nipple, frontally, but under fishnets or transparent clothing. Where do we draw the line?

We don't; the previous time I explained that was here.

You seem to have a problem with uploading this sort of extremely borderline nude image frequently. You should expect a good number of them, possibly seemingly at random to you, will be deleted. If this annoys you, don't upload this sort of image.

3 days ago - permalink

Chainer★:

If you want to argue that it is not an adult image, go ahead...

andronico:

Especially when there are images that have been uploaded that clearly show a nipple, frontally, but under fishnets or transparent clothing. Where do we draw the line?

We don't; the previous time I explained that was here.

You seem to have a problem with uploading this sort of extremely borderline nude image frequently. You should expect a good number of them, possibly seemingly at random to you, will be deleted. If this annoys you, don't upload this sort of image.

Although the thread I'm linking to is regarding nudity on forums, I'd think this is equally relevant to the gallery. Correct me if I'm wrong.

3 days ago - permalink

This video is from the second Instagram account of Emily Nosler https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQrxeQaEU_E/?i...

You can check it

3 days ago - permalink

I see you just joined two weeks ago. Welcome to GWM. You've got some nice uploads so far.

For me as a long time member, not a mod, this one however is adult content all the way. Cheers!

3 days ago - permalink

I see you just joined two weeks ago. Welcome to GWM. You've got some nice uploads so far.

For me as a long time member, not a mod, this one however is adult content all the way. Cheers!

Ok I understood, I posted it because I’ve seen on Instagram so I thought it wouldn’t be a problem if I posted here, but it’s ok Thank you for welcoming me, as you can see I’m a huge fan of female bodybuilding!

tamarok
3 days ago - permalink

I've recently seen some image on Instagram that wouldn't normally make the cut even there. Its possible their mods didn't catch them yet, and anyhow different site, different rules.

3 days ago - permalink

I've recently seen some image on Instagram that wouldn't normally make the cut even there. Its possible their mods didn't catch them yet, and anyhow different site, different rules.

Ok I understood, I’m new on the site, so I just want to get familiar with rules, thanks anyway for the explication

1 day ago - permalink

So, how are these posts more "muscular"...

https://www.girlswithmuscle.com/2692008/ https://www.girlswithmuscle.com/2690805/

...rather than my deleted posts from the same model for 'no visible muscle'?

Chainer
1 day ago - permalink

TBH none of those are really that great.

1 day ago - permalink

TBH none of those are really that great.

And where did I say so? 🥴

I'm here just to get a fair explanation, why mine got deleted unlike the others...

1 day ago - permalink

I reported at least one Jazmin upload by that uploader, the model that you shared, for having no muscle. You can do the same.

Having "toothpick arms" might be an immediate alert that a photo may not have GwM quality.

« first < prev Page 41 of 42 next > last »