Log in | Register
Forum > Announcements > Thread

Changes to the image comment quality filter (aka: your comments no longer get rejected)

Chainer
Dec 13, 2022 - edited Dec 13, 2022 - permalink

More or less exactly how I described here.

To reiterate:

  • All comments are now accepted by the site.
  • The algorithm for determining whether a comment falls below the quality threshold hasn't changed.
  • When you post a comment, there is a delay. If your comment is above the threshold, then after this delay the image is bumped to the front page and notifications are sent out. If your comment is below the threshold, these things don't happen.
  • Low quality comments are hidden by default. Above each thread, if there is at least one comment hidden, you will see a link to show all the hidden comments. (Your own comments are always shown to you by default.)

My goal with this change is to make the filter more user friendly while keeping the spam/noise from low quality comments to a minimum.

Dec 13, 2022 - permalink

Sounds good i have been commenting way less. because i don't like it when my comments get rejected. this system is much better i will comment more now but i will try to keep them decent.

Dec 15, 2022 - permalink

I don't know if this is a good idea, at the end it is same situation like before just hidden and the stupid/spam commenters won.

Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

Sounds good i have been commenting way less. because i don't like it when my comments get rejected. this system is much better i will comment more now but i will try to keep them decent.

Same

Dec 16, 2022 - edited Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

So if you make a comment and it is below the threshold, do you get notified when someone makes another comment (whether it is above or below the threshold)? Presumably not.

Chainer
Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

You do get notified. It's just that other people (before you) don't get notified about your comment.

By the way, you can subscribe to an image without leaving a comment by pressing the "subscribe" button (next to the report button).

cgsweat
Dec 16, 2022 - edited Dec 16, 2022 - permalink
  • When you post a comment, there is a delay. If your comment is above the threshold, then after this delay the image is bumped to the front page and notifications are sent out. If your comment is below the threshold, these things don't happen.

Approximately how long is this delay?

EDIT: It seems to be about 15 minutes, give or take.

EDIT EDIT: Confirmed. The delay is exactly 15 minutes.

cgsweat
Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

It could be a bug, but I received an image comment notification but no comment was displayed when I checked the link. This could be due to the new "delay" you mentioned.

cgsweat
Dec 16, 2022 - edited Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

Also, this comment was apparently flagged by the filter, as I received no notification for it:

Musclewomanlove

10 minutes ago

This woman's size, definition, and strength are world class.

I should have, since the comment came after I had posted a comment of my own, and so I was automatically subscribed to that image's comment notifications.

I see nothing wrong with that comment, however... and as others have pointed out through several comment reports, other, much more egregious comments are "slipping through the cracks."

EDIT: I see... so in this case the notification came several minutes later. I was able to view the comment several minutes before I received the notification for it.

Dec 16, 2022 - permalink

It has a big issue with people complementing a woman's strength. i guess that is just as bad as making obscene innuendos. because it's shmoe behavior and not serious enough.

Dec 17, 2022 - permalink

Sometimes I would not even call it complementing but just plain exaggerating and fantasizing.

Now whenever I hear the word I think of some whiner protesting how good and innocent he is. I'm talking about stuff like "she must be deceptively strong". I mean, why? What makes you (whoever makes those comments) think that? And why deceptively? Why not just strong? And why even that? Bodybuilders aren't strength athletes even half the time. I would take honest obscenity over dishonest sucking up any day.

Chainer
Dec 17, 2022 - edited Dec 18, 2022 - permalink

Yes, the delay is 15 minutes. Arguably this is too long, and I should shorten it.

EDIT: I see... so in this case the notification came several minutes later. I was able to view the comment several minutes before I received the notification for it.

I should put in logic that prevents a notification from being sent to anyone who has left a comment on that image after the time of the notifying comment.

Edit: I fixed it

Chainer
Dec 17, 2022 - permalink

Also, while musclewomanlove's comment quoted above did not get hit by the filter, generally the answer to "Why did my comment get filtered while this almost identical other comment did not?" is that you have made many similar comments recently, while the other user has not.

Mar 05, 2023 - permalink

I wonder if there should still be some agreed upon limit to what can be posted even in this situation.

Two comments, to the same picture, from someone called Derrynice:

Wow! Mak... I can imagine how hard you could punch me in the mouth. I wouldn't be standing! I will be beaten and bleeding yet inspired and turned on by your beautiful built muscles. You are my dream bodyguard girl! xx💓

Wow! Mak... I can only imagine how hard you could punch a grown man in the face. If I were the victim wouldn't be standing! I will be smashed and bleeding yet inspired and turned on by your gorgeous sexy built muscles. You are my ideal bodyguard! xx💓

Makes me wonder if he posted the second one after he saw the first one got censored. Either he thought that it failed to appear or he wanted to make it public, though failed to do so.

Now I can't tell anyone what to do. This is why I am only asking. I think there are different levels to this stuff.

On the first level is mutual combat. "She could probably beat me in a fair fight."

On the second level is BDSM and domination. "She could probably make me feel lots of pain."

On the third level are degrading and humiliating acts, sometimes involving bodily orifices and secretions, things forced onto or into persons. Sounds NSFW, so won't give any examples here.

On the fourth level is injury, physical damage and disfigurement and other life-changing stuff. And maybe you could add a fifth level for dismemberment and death.

I would draw the line between the second and the third. Or at least dispel the idea that since the comment is censored, anything goes. Of course nobody can be stopped from having private fantasies of being beaten to a pulp or eaten alive or watching Shefights or reading Sandi Stone stories.

Mar 10, 2023 - permalink

Hello, How do i choose to activate a hidden comment please ? I really don't get the point about hiding some pleasing rhapsodic comments with no offense at all !

Thank you

Mar 10, 2023 - permalink

I would love the option to automatically show hidden comments, in the site settings.

Mar 10, 2023 - permalink

I would love the option to automatically show hidden comments, in the site settings.

Yes !!! That's a good solution. Or a button to "unhide" a comment is even better !

Mar 10, 2023 - permalink

I would love the option to automatically show hidden comments, in the site settings.

agreed.

Jun 17, 2023 - permalink

I wish there was an option to privately add people to censored comments. Or individual comments. Case in point is that here are a few users who don't get off on these women at all, but rather their own voice.

This could maybe then used as "training data" for the filter. I know the filter does not use AI, but Chainer could maybe get new ideas by looking at the list of what people have hidden.

"She's definitely strong, I can tell you that for sure." And the same written to thousands upon thousands of pictures with no idea if the woman is a strength athlete or not (usually not). Just look at goodoc2001's comment history for example. Or these are comments of people talking to themselves to get off and find it more convincing if they write it publicly.

"She's stronger than she looks" superficially looks like information on the model but is in fact the equivalent of a simple boing.

« first < prev Page 1 of 1 next > last »