Log in | Register
Forum > General / Nonfiction > Thread

Why is Melissa Brodsky blacklisted?

Oct 13, 2021 - permalink

Title. It seems like it happened very recently given she was always on the top post pages until the last month or so.

Oct 13, 2021 - permalink

It's the woman's choice, so it really shouldn't be anyone's business but her own, honestly.

Oct 14, 2021 - permalink

Agreed yeah. Though I would imagine it's mostly (1) a decent amount of creepy comments that she can't moderate or control and (2) desire to control her own content

Chainer
Oct 14, 2021 - permalink

Because she requested to be removed.

I'm not really sure what answer people expect when they ask "why is X blacklisted", insert any value for X...

Oct 15, 2021 - permalink

Probably due to the fact that many women don't enjoy being preyed, DM'd and creeped on. I presume this was the case anyhow. Like everyone here it's fine to find athletic or muscular women attractive, but some people seriously cross that respectful border and creepily objectify other human beings.

Oct 15, 2021 - permalink

Probably due to the fact that many women don't enjoy being preyed, DM'd and creeped on. I presume this was the case anyhow. Like everyone here it's fine to find athletic or muscular women attractive, but some people seriously cross that respectful border and creepily objectify other human beings.

Knowing quite a few muscular women through my gym and competitions I have been at, this is very true. You would shudder at just how many creepy and gross comments and DMs they get. It wouldn’t surprise me if Melissa got one too many dumb comments and pulled the plug on having her pics here.

It’s fine to be attracted to what you’re attracted to, and most muscular women actually like it when people find them attractive. What they hate, however, are the creepy comments. Don’t ruin it for the rest of us.

Oct 15, 2021 - permalink

Probably due to the fact that many women don't enjoy being preyed, DM'd and creeped on. I presume this was the case anyhow. Like everyone here it's fine to find athletic or muscular women attractive, but some people seriously cross that respectful border and creepily objectify other human beings.

Yeah that sadly comes with the overall scene -- I'm sure she gets a lot of that on IG too. But IG is her main business platform, so it's worth it.

I think the fact that she can't control individual comments is the main factor. She's repping a few different brands and probably doesn't want to appear like an explicit sex object (even if she's absolutely an implicit one). If you're trying to

She can delete comments that she doesn't like on IG. That's out of her control here. So it's just easier to remove herself altogether.

Oct 15, 2021 - edited Oct 15, 2021 - permalink

There's a couple of pages of pics of her on beautymuscle (dot) net, but there doesn't seem to be any place for comments there. Perhaps she's OK with having her pics posted without comments, or perhaps that site ignored demands that her pics be taken down.

There are four pages of her on Saradas, including tons of contest pics to which she made herself vulnerable by competing. The Saradas site allows posting of comments as well as photos, but comments are rare in general and there don't seem to be any about Ms. Brodsky.

CORRECTION: No comments on first page. Later pages include the following:

Quote from: MCfanII on September 22, 2021, 01:58:09 am Practically perfect in every way!

Thanks for the positive feedback! Ms. Brodsky is looking very fine.

She hot ...

I hope she moves up to physique soon. She is an absolute dime though. [COMMENT: Is that creepy? Is a "dime" a 10-cent whore?]

----end of comments quoted from Saradas----

An "images" search for "Melissa Brodsky" will find many other photos of her on sites other than her InstaGram page.

And in the "creepy" category, there's a deviant (perhaps literally) on DeviantArt posting wrestling fantasy texts of Ms. Brodsky against other female bodybuilders, such as Amanda Machado.

« first < prev Page 1 of 1 next > last »